When Academia Meets the Blogosphere
Theda Skocpol, the Victor S. Thomas Professor of Government and Sociology and former Dean of the Graduate School at Harvard University, has been blogging for TPMCafe. In yesterday's post, "True Campaign Reform: Bring People into Politics," Skocpol attempted to defend from a civic engagement perspective Barack Obama's decision to stay out of the public financing system for the 2008 general election campaign. One TPMCafe reader blasted Skocpol, prompting this response from another reader:
You might want to think twice before you use such a pedestrian blog-o-sphere insult with one of America's most distinguished social scientists.
This mode of interaction is extraordinarily democratic, you get to talk trash to a Harvard dean. But since Prof. Skocpol is here, I'm sure she knows what she is getting into. And being a professor doesn't always make her right, but I would guess she knows a little more about social and political movements than you do.
So you might want to show a little respect and perhaps try to learn something or at least engage in a more thoughtful discourse. Sorry "this isn't the 1800's" probably doesn't pass for a thoughtful argument.
Should scholars receive respect and deferential treatment when they enter the blogosphere? Clearly civility and traditional mores do not seem to apply in cyberspace. However, some scholars would argue that academic department meetings often lack civility and respectful behavior.